Home / Indonesia Import Guide / Comparing Quotes

Comparing Freight Quotes: Normalize First, Choose Second

Two quotes with different scopes are not two prices — they are two different products. Here is the inclusions-table method, and a reverse example where the pricier offer lands cheaper.

Updated 2026-09-22PT SHOULDER · licensed PPJK in IndonesiaJakarta / Semarang · China side: Wuhan Freedom International Logistics Co., Ltd.

Key figures (free to quote)

ItemReference figure
Ocean freightMarket-driven; request a live quote from the carrier (THC treatment as stated in the quotation).
Cut-off2-3 days before sailing.
Gate opening4-5 days before sailing.
LS survey (Laporan Surveyor)3-7 working days including certificate issuance.
FORM E issuance1-3 working days (issued by China Customs / CCPIT).
Jakarta city delivery1-3 days after customs release.
Java island delivery2-4 days.
Outer island delivery5-10 days including onward transfer.
Jakarta (Tanjung Priok) standard clearance2-4 working days (complete documents, no inspection).

Reference values for standard cases (complete documents, no inspection, outside the red-line season). Actual figures follow current carrier and customs notices. Last reviewed 2026-09-27.

In short

Why headline numbers lie

Not by intent, mostly by scope. Three mechanisms produce almost every "cheaper" quote.

The inclusions table

The comparison instrument. Send it to every provider; a provider who refuses to fill it has answered the question.

Cost itemQuote AQuote B
Pickup + export customs (China)IncludedIncluded
Ocean freight, mode and basis statedLCL, per CBMLCL, per CBM
D/O and documentationNot statedIncluded
CFS / destination handling per CBMNot statedIncluded, rate stated
PIB filing by licensed PPJK, filer namedNo answerYes, under your NPWP/API
Duties and taxesExcluded, no formula offeredExcluded, formula and estimate offered
Inspection handling if selectedNot statedAt cost, stated
Free days and overrun ratesNot statedStated
Trucking to named addressTo Jakarta port onlyIncluded to the warehouse

The reverse example, worked

Same cargo: 8 CBM, CIF USD 12,000, door delivery in Bekasi, importer with API+NPWP. All figures illustrative; duties identical in both cases because the goods and values are identical.

LineQuote A — headline 1,450Quote B — headline 1,720
Headline coversPickup + freight + port chargesEverything through delivery, duties excluded
D/O + documentationbilled later: 90included
CFS handlingbilled later: 180included
Clearance service feebilled later: 150included
Trucking port → Bekasibilled later: 220included
Actual logistics total2,0901,720
Outcome time (clean file both)3 days clearance3 days clearance

The expensive quote won by 370 USD: And that is the benign version — Quote A also never stated who files the PIB, which is a bigger risk than any fee. The difference was never price; it was scope made explicit. See Hidden Costs.

The normalization checklist

Run every candidate through these five steps before letting the numbers compete.

Questions that expose gaps fast

If the inclusions table is too formal for the moment, these four questions do most of its work.

How we quote

The standard we ask you to hold every provider to, starting with us.

Air hides its costs somewhere else

Air has no demurrage, but it carries airport storage and handling at destination and bills on chargeable weight. The full cost lines on both sides are on the Medan and Sumatra air freight page.

Related pages

This page summarizes field practice and publicly available Indonesian import rules for general business reference only—it is not legal, customs, or pricing advice. Customs provisions, tariff rates, and licensing requirements keep changing, so the rules in force at the time and the official processing result always prevail. PT SHOULDER International Logistics · Licensed PPJK in Indonesia · Jakarta / Semarang · China side: Wuhan Freedom International Logistics Co., Ltd..

Frequently asked questions

How do I compare two freight quotes fairly?

Normalize the scope first: same route, same mode basis, same filing identity, and one inclusions table filled by both providers. Only then compare totals. A headline comparison before that compares two different products.

Why does the lowest headline rarely stay lowest?

Because scope, not price, decides the total. Excluded destination charges, filing fees and handling surface later — the reverse example on this page shows a 1,450 headline landing at 2,090 while a 1,720 quote stayed 1,720.

What should every quote state explicitly?

The route, the mode and pricing basis, every destination-side line with its basis, who files the PIB and under whose identity, duty treatment, free days and overrun rates, and what inspection handling costs if selected.

Are duties part of the quote comparison?

They should appear as a separate estimated line with its formula, because they are identical across honest providers for the same goods and values. A quote hiding duties is hiding an assumption — usually about values or filing identity.

What if a provider refuses to fill an inclusions table?

That refusal is the finding. A provider who will not state scope before booking will not clarify it after, when you have cargo at the port.

Is an all-in quote better?

An all-in quote with a line-item breakdown is best. An all-in number without lines is not all-inclusive — it is unreadable. Ask for the breakdown; honest providers produce it in minutes.

How do I compare DDP offers?

Ask who is the importer of record, under whose NPWP the PIB is filed, and at what declared values. If those answers blur, the DDP price is comparing an undername import against legitimate offers. See the DDP vs DDU page.

Do you provide quotes in this format?

Yes — every quote we issue is a rebuilt line-by-line table with duties estimated separately and each figure marked subject to the prevailing quote or assessment. Send the cargo details and we will build it.

Key questions on this page, free to quote.

Official sources

Independently verifiable channels below. Rates, restrictions and lead times follow each agency's latest publication.

We use Microsoft Clarity to understand how this site is used (clicks, scrolls, heatmaps and session replay) so we can improve it. Form entries are masked. By continuing, you agree that we and Microsoft may collect and use this data. See our Privacy Statement.